A Teacher Asks:
I currently have several autistic students (seven, to be exact) who are completely unable to write essays or structured texts. Every single one of them has an excellent vocabulary and scores exceptionally high in reading comprehension, reading speed, grammar, spelling, and general word knowledge. In terms of language development, they don’t have any actual deficits.
Unfortunately, to pass their Language Arts classes, students are required to organize and compose various types of texts. I have tried everything my creative brain and years of teaching experience can come up with—templates, outlines, bulleted lists, step-by-step instructions—but nothing works. They just freeze. It’s a total mental block.
One student told me that what’s in their head just won’t come out on paper, which frustrates them, or that they can’t get the “right” words out. It’s almost as if they feel that if a first draft isn’t absolutely perfect from the get-go, it shouldn’t be written down at all. To combat this, I’ve sat down with them to co-write drafts, showing them how we can tweak the text later to get it just right. I’ve tried having them speak while I type, giving them the essay prompts well in advance, and asking parents to help them prepare notes to bring to class. I’ve tried so many things.
Is there any known strategy or help for autistic individuals dealing with this specific type of “writer’s block”?
I can only imagine how frustrating this must be for the parents, too. They see that their child has all the potential in the world, yet the kid can’t get a single word out on a computer or a piece of paper. The parents often believe that with the “right kind of support” at school, the student will just snap out of it. But that’s not how it works—especially not in cases like this.
I teach middle school, where assignments are getting longer and more advanced, and the pace is fast. As I mentioned, I’ve exhausted my entire pedagogical toolkit, and I can tell this issue isn’t about language skills, writing techniques, or a developmental delay.
I would be so grateful for any advice on where to look for help. These students need a way to understand what’s happening in their own minds.
Paula Responds:
First of all, I am so sorry for taking so long to get back to you! I’ve been in the middle of a chaotic move. I actually read your message a while ago, but my brain was completely fried at the time, so I put off replying and then it slipped my mind (I’m still pretty exhausted from the move, so I’m more forgetful than usual). Please accept my apologies!
Check out my previous posts
Struggling with different types of writing seems to be a very common hurdle in autism. Because we autistic individuals tend to have a highly uneven spiky cognitive profile, performing on demand can be incredibly difficult, especially when the pressure is on.
Try writing in Spanish or French first
Some autistic people actually find it much easier to express themselves in a foreign language, like Spanish or French, rather than their native English. If any of your students are particularly good at a second language, you might want to let them try writing their initial thoughts in that language first. If they can master the structure of an essay in Spanish or French first, translating or adapting those ideas back into English afterward might feel less daunting. This trick doesn’t work for every autistic person, but many are highly proficient in foreign languages. Writing in a non-native language can provide a sense of emotional distance from the text, which lowers anxiety.
Focus on microscopic details, not the big picture
Another approach is to completely shift the focus from the big picture to tiny details. Looking at an assignment as a “whole essay” requires a massive amount of high-level conceptual processing, which can cause total overwhelm. Instead, have them start with just ONE sentence. Tell the student to pick any sentence they want to include in the piece, and emphasize that it does not have to be perfect! This sentence doesn’t even have to be the introduction; it could be the very last line of the essay. Later on, they can write another sentence, and another. Once they have enough pieces, they can treat them like a jigsaw puzzle and try to assemble a text. The final piece might not flow perfectly at first because some puzzle pieces will inevitably be missing, but refining that flow is a skill they can learn down the road.
Redefine what “notes” look like
You could also encourage them to jot down rough notes or create a mind map if they are a visual learner. Make it clear that these notes don’t need to be full sentences. They can be random words, sketches, or even a mix of different languages. This is exactly how I plan my own lectures! My personal notes are completely incomprehensible to anyone else—they consist of broken words, language mashups, and trigger words that look nothing like the actual sentences I say on stage. The only thing that matters is that I know what they mean. People often have this misconception that notes need to look neat and organized, but that’s a myth. For example, if I want to remind myself of a story from my first year of primary school, I might just write the number “1” on a sticky note, and my brain instantly knows the rest. Honestly, I would never show my notes to anyone because they’d probably think I’ve lost my mind!
Leverage AI tools
Finally, I wonder if there is an opportunity here to utilize AI. You could allow the student to use an AI tool to generate a basic draft, which the student can then rewrite in their own words. Once they get comfortable with that process, you can move to a setup where the AI only generates a list of bullet points, and the student writes the actual text. I know schools have strict rules about using AI for graded exams and finals, but using it as a scaffold practice sessions could be an absolute game-changer for breaking through that initial paralysis!
Leave a comment or read other people’s comments on this post. By submitting a comment, you agree to my comment rules.
Book Me
Please reach out to me via the contact form if you’d like to book me for a lecture on autism or an interview about my life with autism. You can find more information about me and my lectures here.
Follow Me
Feel free to follow my blog via Facebook, Instagram or RSS. To follow the blog via RSS, you’ll need an RSS reader. Some examples include Fluent Reader (Windows) or Raven (Windows/Mac OS/Linux), Feeder (Android), or NetNewsWire (iOS). Simply copy the blog’s RSS feed address into the reader.
If You Need Emotional Support
Don’t be afraid to reach out for help if life feels hopeless! Here’s a list of helplines and phone support services in the US you can contact if you need assistance. For people outside the US this page lists helplines for people in need of immediate mental help support during a mental health crisis.